USA / England · 1932–1963

Could You Have Been
Sylvia Plath?

She wrote her greatest poems — the Ariel poems — in the final four months of her life, waking at 4am before her babies stirred in the coldest English winter in 300 years. She was 30 years old, separated from her husband Ted Hughes, living in Yeats's old flat in Fitzroy Road. She wrote 40 poems in 40 days. She left milk and bread for her children. She sealed their room with towels. On February 11, 1963, she put her head in the oven.
40
Ariel poems written in 40 days before her death
30
Years of age — died at the age of peak creative power
1982
Posthumous Pulitzer Prize — 19 years after death
Chapter 1 · Massachusetts, 1953 · The First Breakdown

You are 20 years old and a junior at Smith College on a scholarship you cannot afford to lose. You have been awarded a guest editorship at Mademoiselle magazine in New York — a month in the city, a prize the most ambitious college women in America compete for. It should be the beginning. Instead it is the end of something. New York paralyzes you. The glitter turns cold. You come home and discover you have not been accepted to Frank O'Connor's Harvard writing seminar. Something in you breaks. You stop sleeping. You stop reading. Your mother finds you in the cellar, covered in blood from a self-inflicted wound, having taken sleeping pills. You survive with electroconvulsive therapy and months of psychiatric treatment.

Decision 1 · After the First Breakdown
You have survived a serious breakdown and treatment at McLean Hospital. You return to Smith on scholarship. Do you write about what happened?
What actually happened: Plath waited nine years, until 1962, to write The Bell Jar — and published it under the pseudonym Victoria Lucas because she feared the reaction in America, where her mother lived. The book is a precise, darkly comic account of the breakdown from the inside. It was published in England in January 1963, one month before her death, to moderate reviews. It was published in America in 1971 and became one of the defining texts of its decade. The pseudonym did not hold — her identity was known within months.
Chapter 2 · Cambridge, 1956 · Ted Hughes

You are 23, on a Fulbright scholarship to Newnham College, Cambridge. On February 25, 1956, you attend a party for the launch of a Cambridge literary journal. You read a poem by a young Yorkshireman called Ted Hughes in the magazine beforehand and know immediately that this is a real poet — larger than the Cambridge poets who write careful, modest verse. At the party you meet him. He is six feet tall, dark, physically overwhelming. You bite his cheek hard enough to draw blood at the end of your first conversation. He takes your headband and earrings. You are married four months later.

Decision 2 · The Marriage
You marry Ted Hughes quickly, passionately, and against the American custom of careful courtship. You know this is a gamble. Is the gamble right?
What actually happened: Plath married Hughes in June 1956. The marriage was the most productive period of her life — she finished The Colossus, her first poetry collection, and drafted early work toward what became Ariel while they lived in England and America. She was also, by every account, managing the household, the children, and the secretarial work for Hughes's career while writing her own work. The intensity was generative for nearly seven years. It ended when Hughes left her for Assia Wevill in the summer of 1962. Plath wrote the Ariel poems in the months that followed. The catastrophe and the masterpiece were the same event.
Chapter 3 · Devon, 1962 · Discovery

You are living in a farmhouse in Devon with two children under two, a husband who has been increasingly absent, and the knowledge that has been forming slowly for months and is now certain: Ted Hughes is having an affair with Assia Wevill. The day you confirm it you disconnect the phone with a pair of scissors. You rip his manuscript pages. You burn his papers in the garden — letters, notebooks. Then you go inside and write. The poems you write in the following weeks are unlike anything you have written before. They are furious, exact, and absolute. You will call the collection Ariel.

Decision 3 · The Poems
The poems you are writing in the weeks after the marriage collapse are your best work — raw, angry, precise. Do you restrain them for publication?
What actually happened: Plath did not restrain the poems. They were exactly what they were — "Lady Lazarus," "Daddy," "Fever 103°," "Cut." The specific anger and precision of the imagery is what makes them permanent. When Ted Hughes edited and published Ariel in 1965, two years after her death, he reordered the manuscript and removed several poems. The version of Ariel he published is not the version she planned. Her original ordering was only restored in 2004 when Frieda Hughes, Plath's daughter, supervised a facsimile edition. For forty years, the world read Ted Hughes's version of Sylvia Plath's work.
Chapter 4 · London, Winter 1962–1963 · Fitzroy Road

You have moved to London with your two children. You are living in W.B. Yeats's old flat at 23 Fitzroy Road — you felt the address was a sign. It is the coldest winter in England since 1740. The pipes freeze. The children have colds. Your au pair has quit. Your doctor has prescribed antidepressants but they haven't taken effect yet. You are waking at 4am each day and writing at the kitchen table in the dark, by the light of the single lamp, before the children wake. In these pre-dawn hours in January 1963 you write the poems that will change what poetry can do.

Decision 4 · The 4am Hours
You are writing your best work in the only hours available — 4am to 8am, before two young children need you. Do you protect those hours at all costs?
What actually happened: Plath protected those hours absolutely. The sequence of poems from January 1963 — written in approximately forty days — constitutes one of the most concentrated bursts of great poetry in the English language. "Ariel," "Lady Lazarus," "Edge," "Words." She was exhausted, she was depressed, the antidepressants weren't working yet, the winter was the coldest in three centuries. She wrote anyway. The poems are the record of that writing — you can feel the exhaustion and the absolute attention at the same time.
Chapter 5 · London, February 1963 · The Last Week

The antidepressants have not taken hold. Your doctor has arranged a hospital bed for you but the bed is not available until Monday. You cannot sleep. You are calling friends at 3am. Your neighbor, the poet Gael Turnbull, is woken by your voice. You go to the doctor on Saturday and tell him you are afraid to be alone. He arranges for a nurse to come Monday morning. It is Saturday night. Monday morning is 36 hours away. You go home to Frieda and Nicholas.

Decision 5 · The Last Weekend
You are in a crisis and alone with two small children. The hospital bed is ready Monday. What do you do with Saturday night and Sunday?
What actually happened: On February 11, 1963, Plath put out bread and milk for the children, sealed their bedroom door with tape, and left the gas on. She was found at 9am when the nurse arrived. She was 30 years old. The Ariel manuscript was on the table, completed and ordered. She had written "Edge" — the last poem — on February 5: "The woman is perfected. / Her dead / Body wears the smile of accomplishment." Six days later she was dead. The question of whether she expected to survive, whether the timing of the nurse's arrival was miscalculated, is still debated.
Chapter 6 · The Manuscript

Plath left Ariel in order: 40 poems, arranged by her, beginning with the word "Love" and ending with the word "spring." Ted Hughes, as her literary executor, waited two years to publish it, reordered the manuscript, removed poems including "The Rabbit Catcher" and "Barren Woman," and added poems she had not included. He did not explain these changes for decades. The Ariel the world read from 1965 to 2004 was his version. The Ariel she intended was finally published in 2004.

Decision 6 · The Editorial Question
Ted Hughes changed the manuscript before publication. He was the literary executor. Was this his right?
What actually happened: Hughes's editorial choices remain controversial. His version of Ariel opened with "Morning Song" and ended with the bee-keeping sequence — a more accessible, somewhat more hopeful arc. Her version opened with "Love set you going like a fat gold watch" and ended with "spring" — an arc she had clearly shaped. The critical consensus since 2004 is that her ordering was the right one and that his changes, whether well-intentioned or self-protective, altered the work's meaning. The controversy also produced an unexpected consequence: it made readers attend to Plath more carefully than they might have otherwise.
Chapter 7 · The Legacy Dispute

For decades after her death, Ted Hughes controlled the Plath estate and refused to give scholars access to key documents, including her journals — the last of which he acknowledged destroying. He said he destroyed it to protect their children from its contents. Critics said he destroyed it to protect himself. He published Birthday Letters, his own account of the marriage and its end, in 1998, the year before his death — a book of poems that was immediately celebrated as a masterwork. He died before the critical response to it could fully form.

Decision 7 · The Biographic Problem
The life and the work are entangled in ways that are impossible to separate. Does knowing the biography change the poetry?
What actually happened: The critical consensus has shifted over decades. Early Plath criticism was intensely biographical. Later criticism pushed back against this and tried to read the poems formally, on their own terms. More recent work has returned to the biography but more carefully — noting, for instance, that "Daddy" is not simply about Otto Plath but about a particular kind of cultural authority, that "Lady Lazarus" is not simply confessional but theatrical and archly self-aware. The poems reward both approaches. They are so precisely made that they survive every kind of reading.
Chapter 8 · The Question

She died at 30. The poems written in the last four months of her life — written in a foreign country in a frozen winter while managing two children alone and waiting for antidepressants to take hold — are among the finest poems in the English language. "Lady Lazarus," "Daddy," "Ariel," "Edge." They teach themselves. They have been translated into every language in the world.

Decision 8 · What This Means
The greatest poems she wrote were written in the worst circumstances of her life. Is this a lesson, a coincidence, or a tragedy?
What actually happened: The most careful answer is that the 4am hours — the circumstance, not the suffering — produced the poems. She needed quiet, uninterrupted time to work at the deepest level, and the only way she had that in those final months was to wake before the children. The suffering gave the poems their material. The 4am quiet gave them their form. Both were necessary. Neither was sufficient alone. She would have produced great work in better circumstances. She might have produced more of it. We have only what she wrote.
Continue Exploring

Explore More Historical Simulators

50+ historical figures — scientists, artists, composers, writers. Each one, eight decisions.

See All Simulators